Metabolism, Thou Sucketh
December 14, 2009
After more than a week on my bare-bones plan of eating, which averaged between 1300-1450 calories my weight actually went up a couple more pounds. It makes no sense. I step on the scales, tell D what the numbers are and both of us just scratch our heads. In case you’re wondering my thyroid is just fine and I’m being accurate on my caloric intake, courtesy of weighing and measuring my food and then entering it into an online database that calculates calories and nutritional information. There’s no logic to what’s going on here aside from the fact that this is something I’ve struggled with for years. My body simply does what it will do and seems to be tenaciously resistant to releasing weight. To say I’ve been experiencing some frustration the last few days would be an understatement.
There’s a theory that’s bantered around that after years of yo-yo dieting, and I have about 40 years of up and down and up, that we actually cause change to our metabolism which makes our bodies resistant to losing weight and it’s the only thing I’m able to come up with that explains what’s going on.
Here’s how the theory goes: Our body takes in calories as energy and metabolism is the process by which those calories are burned to keep our body fully functioning. The calories that aren’t burned as energy are either expended as waste or stored as fat; fat being the body’s warehouse supply for backup energy. In case you’re sent to Mars in a space ship and forget to pack lunch as a for instance. When we reduce our calories through dieting our body isn’t getting enough energy in and so it turns to the back up supply, burning stored fat which leads to weight loss. When we stop dieting and raise the calories we’re taking in again, the body stops tapping from the stored fat and returns to it’s usual process of processing all the energy from what’s incoming and then sending the extra to storage or waste.
It’s a good system. The problem is that when the amount of incoming calories radically fluctuates from scarcity to abundance repeatedly as it does through dieting and binging, dieting and binging, at some point the body makes the calculated decision to reset the metabolic rate to burn fewer calories permanently so it can continue to function consistently regardless of the unpredictability of the incoming energy supply. The effect that has is that to lose weight it takes eating fewer calories to lose the same amount of weight that could have been lost years earlier with more calories and the only way left to raise the reduced rate of energy (calorie) burn is to increase physical activity, forcing the body to convert more incoming calories and stored fat (reserve calories) into energy.
Thus concludes all I know about metabolism 101.
So this is my best guess as to what I’m currently experiencing in terms of my weight. Through years of yo-yo dieting my metabolism has been reset to function at a much lower rate that it once was and because my physical activity has been severely reduced as a result of my surgical recovery time and now that physical limitations are again in place to not aggravate my hernia until it’s repair in another month, my body is needing very few calories to keep going. That leaves me with three options.
- Feel sorry for myself, throw in the towel and hurry down the street to In-N-Out for a double-double animal style burger. Not an option.
- Stay with my bare-bones food plan and accept where my weight goes until I can return to my full activity level, allowing me to gradually lose any increase that’s occurred in my weight. While this seems the most sensible route to take, my weight is so unstable that I have genuine concerns as to where my weight would be by the first of March when I would be back to my full activity level.
- Return to the full liquid fast until I can bring my weight back to the range where I feel it needs to be for optimal health and to achieve a 25 BMI I should weigh between 145-152 pounds. I decided a couple days ago to go with option 3 which reduces my caloric intake to well under 1000 calories and has already caused my body to release about four pounds.
Obviously I don’t want to be fasting. It’s not fun and I don’t like it. Call me crazy but I enjoy eating food. I like sitting down at the table with my adorable little portions of chicken, veggies and rice and spending a few minutes together. But the honest truth is, that after the surgeries I’ve had to remove the excess skin and the new shape that came with them, the anxiety level around shifts in my weight has been heightened off the charts. You know how it is after you’ve worked really hard to stick with a diet that you’ve had some success with and then to come off that diet and see the pounds slowly start to add up again? Multiple your feelings by five and you have some idea of how this feels.
So for now, until the weight settles back down (hopefully within a couple weeks) and I can get my crazy head together (I suspect that might take a little longer), I’m back on the fast. Aside from my whining in this post, I realize there are just some things I’m going to need to learn how to accept in terms of my body, how it responds, how it looks, and where it will ultimately end up leveling off poundage wise. I can only do what I can do and then leave the rest to God and my metabolism to work out together.
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!
Posted in 
December 14th, 2009 at 2:13 pm
I’m sorry that your body is showing off again. I hate it when that happens. I needed to lose about 200 lbs. to get my body to the weight I need to be.
I lost 100 lbs. over a few years on weightwatchers and then I had to have major surgery and was not able to be really active for a while. Gradually the pounds started to come back. I gained about 15 lbs and other than measuring my food and drinking plent of water, there isn’t much I can do right now. Due to family obligations I’m unable to go to the gym right now.
So as soon as these obligations are done, I WILL return to the gym and get my body moving again. Water exercise is about what I can do.
So you will be in my prayers, my Sister, as you go through this struggle.
December 14th, 2009 at 3:51 pm
Anita..we can sucketh together…if that’s OK with D..;-) Trying to balance eating and excercise is a challenge to say the least. I am trying to do enough excercize without hurting my knees. I know less of me would be great for the knees but my body just doesn’t cooperate. I have a …”roving” artheritis. It is in my knees, hips, elbows, sholders etc. Doesn’t hurt everywhere at the same time…just roves around. Trying to get enough excercise to lose weight without crippling myself is nearly impossible. Waa…waaaa where’s the beer. (For cryin in…not drinking, unless it’s lite of course;-) Your honesty and commitment are an inspiration to me to keep up on the perspiration. I’ll keep you in my prayers that you are sucessful at casting out that demon of fat!
December 14th, 2009 at 4:13 pm
My gym tells me that muscle weighs more than fat so you’re getting muscles in all the working out. Keep on keeping on….
Katie
December 15th, 2009 at 12:38 am
I have read your post twice now to hear what you are saying and what you are not. You are still in the post surgery stage. you can exercise as you should. I think you should give yourself a break. If you are sticking to the correct amount of calories, then just relax and dont be fearful. When you are upand running, all of this be behind you and the pounds will drop.
Take heart my friend. Dont punish your body. it needs time to heal.
December 15th, 2009 at 8:13 am
superbummer on the missing out on birthday cake.
December 15th, 2009 at 12:26 pm
Amy–> I know. I’m a little disappointed as we had reservations at The Slanted Door for thai food but this just feels the better thing to do for right now. There will always be cake
December 15th, 2009 at 12:30 pm
Kim –> I really appreciate what you’re saying and am working very hard to keep a sensible head about all this and to be kind to my physical body given all it’s been through in this process. The further I get away from all the surgeries I had, the more it’s sinking in the magnitude of the work that was done so I’m trying to keep my feet grounded and move easily ahead. The fear and panic I’m in process of giving over to God and my therapist
December 15th, 2009 at 12:33 pm
Marlene—> I think as Kim suggested to me you really have to work at being gentle with yourself and your expectations of what you can do given your physical limitations. Just doing a little something rather than nothing at all is a huge success. One of the things I’ve learned in this whole process is that when my body’s in pain rather than pushing through the pain there are times the best thing I can do is rest and when I do get moving to do so gently and slowly. We’re doing this together Girl!
December 15th, 2009 at 12:39 pm
Anon–> Despite the small setback you’re had (not that the surgery was small but that the weight gain has been), it sounds like you’re on a good course. Congratulations on the weight loss from one 100 pounder to another. No one really knows what it’s like to carry or lose 100 pounds than someone else who has been there and done that and so I appreciate you joining into the conversation. I look forward to hearing how your own journey progresses!